For many years now there has been a debate among handgun owners as to what the single most effective selfdefense handgun cartridge is. This is the definitive methodology for predicting the stopping power of handgun loads, the first to take into account what really happens when a bullet meets a man. Pistol rounds provide more stopping power only if the rifle rounds miss or the rifle is out of ammo. Trustworthy statistics on handgun stopping power the topic of handgun stopping power always draws an audience. Video armed cop learns a hard lesson about handgun. Aug 26, 2014 i think that the article named the myth of handgun stopping power is a bit misleading. This is a confusing topic for gun newbies it would seem at the outset that. All experienced revolver men should carry the federal 357b in a. Firearm stopping power fact, fiction and anecdotes.
Read medical statistics made easy second edition by michael harris gordon taylor 2008 paperback pdf handgun stopping power the definitive study read essential dental public health read mainstreaming midwives the politics of change ebook the nature and property of soils ebook formal verification an essential toolkit. An alternate look at handgun stopping power page 6 the. Handgun ammo stopping power all of us have been exposed to the varying theories regarding which type of handgun bullet is best for defensive purposes. They have tabulated every shooting they could find by caliber and ammo brand and rate the % of one shot stops with a body hit. Let me start by saying that the the notion of a 100% guaranteed stopper round is a myth at best and and moneygrubbing lie at worst. Studies of stopping power are irrelevant because no one has ever been able to define how much power, force, or kinetic energy, in and of itself, is required to effectively stop a violent and determined adversary quickly, and even the largest of handgun calibers are not capable of delivering such force. Both books predicted the effectiveness of all types of ammunition by studying the results of reallife shootings rather than relying on laboratory tests that ignored the dynamics of an actual. Another handgun stopping power study the optics talk. I would suggest that anyone with an interest in the subject read those books and decide for themselves. Read medical statistics made easy second edition by michael harris gordon taylor 2008 paperback pdf handgun stopping power the definitive study read essential dental public health read mainstreaming midwives the politics of change ebook the nature and property of soils ebook formal verification an essential toolkit for. Reference scale for ammo stopping power as rated on the hatcher scale. The language is very easy to understand all the people, so do certainly not worry, you can easy to read it. But prompted by tragedies within law enforcement, the debut of such new cartridges. I just watched a pdf that is too large to post but it boiled down to after all the test were completed the best stoppingkilling power was using a hp bullet 357 mag.
Stopping power is the ability of a firearm or other weapon to cause a target human or animal to be incapacitated. The point is to cause a bad guy to cease hostile action, even though he does not not want to. Julian hatcher, a former technical editor at american rifleman, based his theory of relative stopping power on this study and concluded the. The fbi did a study back when revolvers were the choice for most police departments. In january 1992 evan marshall and edwin sanow wrote a book, handgun stopping power. If he doesnt stop you dont stop pulling the trigger. Mar 06, 2017 in january 1992 evan marshall and edwin sanow wrote a book, handgun stopping power. Stopping power top loads for each caliber brand bullet shootings one shot stops percent penetration federal 308 168 gr match 112 110 98% 24. Another handgun stopping power study the optics talk forums. How the myth of the one shot stop has taken over the handgun shooting community instead of taking on the mantle of responsibility and learning proper shot pl. Evan marshall and ed sanow rocked the firearms world with the release of handgun stopping power and street stoppers. If you are new to shooting and self defense this will become one of the most important articles you ever read.
Thee are handguns will take anyone down, but to respond to this article a bit more intelligently i have to define some terms, then describe the issue that can affect this behavior, and end with some conclusions. Jun 17, 2010 pistol rounds provide more stopping power only if the rifle rounds miss or the rifle is out of ammo. Of all the pistol calibers available, the 9mm luger or parabellum is. See all 3 formats and editions hide other formats and editions. Julian hatcher believe that bigger is better while the national institute of justice performed a computer man study a number of years ago which suggested that light and. The best known of the handgun stopping power studies are those of evan marshall and the police marksmans association pma. For at least 50 years gun writers have been absorbed with the issue of which handgun has the most stopping. Their data is up to date and based on actual shootings, not theory. Sanow is the author of more than 1,000 articles on ammunition and stopping power. Stopping power is the capacity of a firearm to incapacitate an attacker when he is shot. The definitive study contain a lot of information on it.
Marshall and sanow have published three entire books on handgun stopping power. For at least 50 years gun writers have been absorbed with. Sep 21, 2014 handgun stopping power is simply a myth. I expected to be castigated by all the big bullet aficionados for reporting honest data about the mouse gun calibers.
The definitive study paperback january 1, 1992 by evan marshall author, edwin j. Jun 09, 2010 stopping power is the capability of a bullet to disrupt nervous system function enough that somebody loses consciousness. What pistols have the best stopping power and controllability. The most effective caliber for stopping power is the one that youve practiced with enough to handle with confidence and skill. The debate generally centers on three options, the 9mm. The term handgun stopping power generally relates various opinions about the ability of handguns to create ballistic wounds sufficient to incapacitate a target. Ed sanow is the senior reserve deputy and a 14year veteran with the benton county, indiana, sheriffs department.
The definitive study marshall, evan, sanow, edwin j. An alternate look at handgun stopping power buckeye. Ive been interested in firearm stopping power for a very long time. Stopping power contrasts with lethality in that it pertains only to a weapons ability to incapacitate quickly, regardless of whether or not death ultimately occurs. The ability to stop a fight with a handgun bullet is often a difficult goal to achieve. Of all the pistol calibers available, the 9mm luger or parabellum is the most benign and controllable for the shooter. Both books predicted the effectiveness of all types of ammunition by studying the results of reallife shootings rather than relying on laboratory tests that. If you\ve been around awhile this will still shed some light on a few things we are sure. However, as we say in our advanced stopping power secrets report, a handgun is a relatively ineffective weapon against a humansized aggressor especially when your attacker is bigger. Free pdf handgun stopping power the definitive study youtube. The 5 calibers to claim the most powerful handgun in the world title reupload duration. But prompted by tragedies within law enforcement, the debut of such new cartridges as the. The variables that i can identify are shot placement, projectile shape, projectile velocity, and the mental state of the person being shot.
Handgun stopping power, the myth of the one shot stop youtube. Stopping power is the capability of a bullet to disrupt nervous system function enough that somebody loses consciousness. When marshalls first book came out in 1992, i ordered it immediately, despite the fact that i was a college student and really couldnt afford. He is a team leader with the benton county multiagency response team and the field training officer for the reserve force. Fact there is much misinformation about the effectiveness of handguns on stopping the aggressive actions of humans. Today matters 12 daily practices to guarantee tomorrows success.
For decades, handgun shooters have argued over what is the most effective handgun caliber. Which gun cartridges have the greatest stopping power is a much debated topic. Try handgun stopping power or street stoppers by evan p. Written by greg ellifritz since my handgun stopping power study was published last month in american handgunner magazine, ive received several questions from readers about my data. The definitive study and came to different conclusions than elfritz did, but i never considered their conclusions absolute fact either. This small round is known as the threeeighty acp automatic colt pistol but sometimes called the 9mm short or 9mm kurtz. There is much misinformation about the effectiveness of handguns on stopping the aggressive actions of humans. Stopping power download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. Jun 04, 2017 the 5 calibers to claim the most powerful handgun in the world title reupload duration. The best stopping power is a complex mix of many different factors, including how fast the round is traveling and what it does when it enters the attackers body.
The issue of handgun stopping power is more than a theoretically interesting topic, but one that is critically practical for leos and others dependent upon handguns for selfprotection. Handgun cartridge speed of incapacitation or stopping power. Handgun stopping power, the myth of the one shot stop. The only way to stop a threat with a handgun is to keep shooting until the threat stops. Handgun cartridge speed of incapacitation or stopping. Patrick firearms training unit fbi academy quantico, virginia july 14, 1989 this always made more sense to me than anything else ive seen written on the subject. I believe people are referring to handgun stopping power. Nov 27, 2015 handgun ammunition stopping power update. Both books predicted the effectiveness of all types of ammunition by studying the results of reallife shootings rather than relying on laboratory tests that ignored the dynamics of an actual gunfight. Trustworth statistics on handgun stopping power the high. Feb 04, 2016 how the myth of the one shot stop has taken over the handgun shooting community instead of taking on the mantle of responsibility and learning proper shot pl. Jul 10, 2010 reference scale for ammo stopping power as rated on the hatcher scale.
Jan 18, 2017 handgun stopping power given the primary criteria of control and subsequent physiological reactions experienced in a deadly force situation, a point has to go to the 9mm. I remember reading handguns magazine back in the late 1980s when evan marshall was writing articles about his stopping power studies. Handgun stopping power is a matter of the speed of incapacitation of a deadly human opponent. Stopping power of handgun cartridges bushcraft usa forums. Dramatic firsthand accounts of the results of handgun rounds fired into criminals by cops, storeowners, cabbies and others are the heart and soul of this longawaited book. Handgun wounding factors and effectiveness special agent urey w. To some, this reduces the validity of the study to zero. Your argument about handgun stopping power has been discussed many times before and will be discussed for eternity. The myth of handgun stopping power the shooters log. Handgun stopping power given the primary criteria of control and subsequent physiological reactions experienced in a deadly force situation, a point has to go to the 9mm. Ll the stopping power of different handgun cartridges 2222003 posted on saturday, february 22, 2003 10.
However, the ability to select ammunition designed to protect both officers and citizens is too critical a task to rely on artificial test mediums in sterile lab environments. This dynamic video brings the pages of handgun stopping power and street stoppers to life with compelling interviews of people who have experienced the effects of handgun stopping power from both sides of the gun. Its very popular as the caliber of choice for small pocket pistols but offers much less power than 9mm luger up next. It was a very valid debate when the choice was limited to the 9mm parabellum and the. The most deadly handgun cartridge you can buy for self.